Today at Elseviergate; more potholes and "bumps" on the "shared journey"; please help us find paywalled OpenAccess Elsevier

It's easy (if tedious) to find paywalled Open Access articles in Elsevier journals. You go to Robert Kiley's excellent spreadsheet (curated by Michelle Brook and others) , find publisher = Elsevier , search for the title and go to the journal pages. Here I show how

Wellcome Trust has apparently paid 2797 GBP in APCs for this article (it's just over 1 page long - actually an editorial)

23932517 Elsevier Current Opinion Microbiology The asexual cycle of apicomplexan parasites: new findings that raise new questions. £2,979.00

Search for "The asexual cycle of apicomplexan parasites: new findings that raise new questions." in Google. Yes, you can get it in PubMed and EuropePMC for free. But go to the Elsevier site (normally Science Direct) - where many people would land - and...

What did they get for their money?

elsevier14

 

 

I am waiting for an official statement from Elsevier - not a random comment on my blog about Javascript and marketing FUD such as "share our journey" on "our bumpy road" . A statement that can convince Robert Kiley that Elsevier is competent and committed to Open Access.

I did that on Friday.

Now Elsevier are aware of my investigations , so I looked today and found something different.

elsevier19

 

IT'S CHANGED!!

I have two hypotheses:

  • The Director of Access and Policy and the VP of Products spent their weekend trying to patch up the potholes on their "bumpy road". (translation - the underinvestment and incompetence of their system). If so they've made a terribly botched job of the change. See below.
  • The Elsevier system isn't stable. It's clearly broken - there is no indication that that Elsevier systems give the same result on different sites, different days, etc.

Take your pick. It's clear that Wellcome haven't got value for money (nearly 3000 GBP). Here's what's still wrong.

  • The article isn't labelled Open Access
  • The article has no licence
  • The article doesn't acknowledge Wellcome Trust funding
  • The article is still (C) Elsevier All rights Reserved
  • The Table of Contents for the issue doesn't say "Open Access"
  • Elsevier haven't made a public apology to the author and Wellcome for stopping the world reading this article.

I'll note that this is a 1-page editorial. It's almost certainly not formally peer-reviewed. It's morally scandalous that Elsevier have the brass neck to charge 3000 quid for it. But, as everyone tells me the purpose of publishing is to make money, not communicate science.

Oh, and I predict a message from Elsevier of the form "thanks for informing us, please keep these coming" .  I'm certainly informing my Parliamentary representatives (Julian Huppert, David Willetts and Vince Cable) and asking what parliament is going to do about Elsevier's misselling and misdelivering. And with your help I expect to keep them coming

PLEASE MAIL ME WITH ANY MORE EXAMPLES YOU KNOW OF WHERE PAID APC ARTICLES ARE STILL BEHIND ELSEVIER PAYWALLS. We want to publicise all those potholes.

TIP: University libraries- why don't you mail all academics and ask them to check whether their APC-paid articles are visible and CC-licenced.

 

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Today at Elseviergate; more potholes and "bumps" on the "shared journey"; please help us find paywalled OpenAccess Elsevier

  1. Alicia Wise says:

    Hi Peter,

    Your readers will likely find our article 'Open Access: the Systems Journey' relevant and helpful. It's available at http://www.elsevier.com/connect/open-access-the-systems-journey The fifth comment in the comment thread has been added to address many of the points you raise above, and in other of your blog posts.

    With kind wishes,
    Alicia

    Dr Alicia Wise
    Director of Access & Policy
    Elsevier
    a.wise@elsevier.com
    @wisealic

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>