Since I have recently posted about Molbank (an Open Access journal of chemical structures and syntheses) I started to have a look at some articles. I should emphasize that I am generally in favour of what Molbank is doing (making information freely available I shall discuss exactly how in a week or so.) But the first article I encountered had a feature that even a non-chemist could spot. I have posted the first part of the article after my comments. Note that I can do this as Molbank allows non-commercial use, whereas some commercial publishers would already be reaching for the lawyers... And please do not take this as a criticism of Open Access - almost all chemical papers that we review using software show one or more detectable and avoidable errors. Take it in fact as a compliment to Openness in that Open papers are exposed, are open to criticism in a way that closed access are not.
My main argument is that if we had semantic authoring tools - this type of error could not occur (or would at least prompt the author):
Molbank 2006, M478
Microwave assisted esterification using Fe2(SO4)3.4H2O/concentrated H2SO4 as efficient catalyst
Krunal G. Desai1,*, Kishor R. Desai1 and D. Padmanabhan2
1Department of Chemistry, Synthetic Organic Chemistry Research Laboratory, Veer Narmad South Gujarat University, Surat-395 007 (Gujarat), India.
Tel: (0261) 2258384, Fax: (0261) 2258384
2Board of Radiation and Isotope Technology, Vashi Complex, Navi Mumbai-400 705 (Maharastra), India.
*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed
Received: 27 June 2005 / Accepted: 6 September 2005 / Published: 31 March 2006
Keywords: esterification, Fe2(SO4)3.4H2O/con.H2SO4 as catalyst, microwave effect